30 de agosto de 2012

A lei de cotas e positiva para as federais? sim? Não?



O Estado de São Paulo, 30/8/2012

ANÁLISE
A Lei de Cotas é positiva para as federais?

SIM
Jorge Werthein, doutor por Stanford, é presidente do Centro Brasileiro de Estudos Lantino-Americanos.

O objetivo principal das cotas não é melhorar a universidade, mas tentar democratizar o acesso. Alunos de escolas públicas sempre enfrentaram grandes desigualdades. Concordo plenamente com o clamor dos que falam que é fundamental melhorar a qualidade do ensino básico. E é necessário que isso se acelere. Entretanto, não podemos abrir mão do sistema de cotas mesmo que isso ainda persista no Brasil. A América Latina é a região mais desigual do planeta e o Brasil, o terceiro mais desigual entre esses países. A educação não está imune a essa desigualdade e estamos tentando corrigir isso e aumentar a qualidade. Temos evidências de que aqueles que já ingressaram nas universidades por cotas estão com rendimento comparável ao dos demais. É hora de concentrar esforços para que a lei tenha o melhor impacto. É fundamental que as universidades tenham um programa de apoio para os ingressantes. Mas não só para os cotistas: o ingresso dos alunos está marcado por grandes deficiências, sejam eles de escolas públicas ou privadas.

NÃO
Leandro Tessler, coordenador de Relações Internacionais da Universidade Estadual de Campinas (Unicamp).

As cotas são um péssimo movimento no ensino superior. Ainda bem que isso não engloba as universidades estaduais. Defendo ações afirmativas, mas essa lei é arbitrária e impositiva. No mundo acadêmico, nada substitui o mérito. Esse preceito de sermos todos iguais não vale para a Academia. A universidade é, por natureza, uma meritocracia. O ideal - como ocorre em todos os outros países do mundo - é incentivar as instituições a criarem projetos de ações afirmativas e oferecer estímulos para que cada uma delas pense na melhor forma de incluir esses alunos. Não é por decreto que a gente cria gente capaz e criativa. Aliás, se a ideia é que a universidade reproduza a mesma realidade da sociedade, a meta é tímida: quase 90% dos formandos do ensino médio são da rede pública. Não deveria, então, ser esse o porcentual? Precisamos criar uma elite intelectual egressa da rede pública e - num país racista como ainda é o Brasil - os negros também têm de receber estímulos. Mas fazer isso em detrimento do mérito não faz sentido algum.

(Informações da Agência Brasil e O Estado de São Paulo)

Clinton, Cardoso and Blair Three ex-leaders meet in Brazil



Aug 28th 2012, 19:34 by H.J. | SÃO PAULO

TONY BLAIR and Bill Clinton were in São Paulo on August 28th, speaking at an event run by Itaú BBA, a Brazilian investment bank. Sharing the platform was Fernando Henrique Cardoso, whose two terms as Brazil's president, from 1995 to 2002, overlapped with both visitors' own periods in office. Ilan Goldfajn, the bank's chief economist, moderated a discussion that touched on foreign views of Brazil and Brazilian views of abroad—and what the developed world could learn about handling financial crises from a country that has suffered more than its fair share of them in the past, but is coming through the most recent one much better than most.
The euro and sovereign debt crises, said Mr Blair, had not created the need for reform in Europe's weak peripheral economies, merely exposed that need and made it more acute. Now, sadly, reforms that were neglected in the good times would have to be tackled during a crisis. Before becoming president, Mr Cardoso was Brazil's financial minister, and led the Real Plan which introduced a new currency, stabilised the economy and ended hyperinflation. That makes him a veteran of pushing through reforms during crises—and his take was interesting. "The political situation [in the run-up to the Real Plan] was chaos," he said. "Some people said it would be impossible, but my opinion was the opposite. When you don’t have order it is easier to do something, not harder. Europe is approaching a chaotic situation … when it will be easier to impose new rules."
Is the world suffering a "crisis of capitalism", Mr Goldfajn asked. "I hope not," replied Mr Clinton: "We’re all big free-market guys." But markets tend to contain within them a tendency to self-destruct, he said, and the proper role of government is to try to prevent this from happening. Mr Blair told of bumping into an old friend from university, a Trotyskyite ("mostly they became bankers, but this one really meant it"), who took the opportunity to gloat, saying: "I told you capitalism would fail." But the gains that Brazil has experienced in recent years came from opening up to global trade and sticking to economic orthodoxy, he pointed out. 
The fashion these days, at least in Brazil, said Mr Cardoso, is to say that we need "more state", but this is not the right response to what was a failure of regulation. "We need more regulation, but we must not use the state as an instrument to stop innovation in the markets," he said. Later, asked to say how Brazil's current government looked from his perspective, he acknowledged it was getting many things right, but bemoaned its tendency to try to micromanage the private sector.
It must have been very sweet for Mr Cardoso to be praised for laying the groundwork for Brazil's recent reductions in inequality and poverty. Conquering hyperinflation was the first essential step towards getting Brazil growing and raising its poorest people's incomes, but his reforms were opposed at the time by both Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and his Workers' Party (PT), and their benefits only really started to be felt by the population at large after he left office. But even if for what Mr Clinton called "obvious reasons" neither Lula nor Dilma Rousseff, Mr Cardoso's two PT successors as president, were particularly keen to say so, both continued along the economic lines he had mapped out, and Brazil has been the better for it. 
Mr Clinton also mentioned by name Mr Cardoso's Bolsa Escolar programme, which gave poor families grants to keep their children in school. This was continued and greatly extended by Lula under a new name, Bolsa Família, and is now famous worldwide as a shining example of how to cut child poverty. It rankles with Mr Cardoso's fans that Lula—and his admirers abroad—rarely acknowledge its origins. Mr Cardoso is generally statesmanlike, but it sometimes slips that he finds it offensive the way he was airbrushed out of Brazilian history by Lula, who had been a co-traveller in the fight for democracy during the country’s military dictatorship, and a personal friend. (For more on Mr Cardoso's views on Brazil, Lula and the world, see The Economist's interview with him in January.)
Both Mr Blair and Mr Clinton finished with praise for the immense progress Brazil has made in the last two decades. Mr Blair told of his emotions on watching a documentary about Ayrton Senna, a much-loved Brazilian racing driver who was killed in a crash in 1994. It includes footage of reaction in the streets, with grieving Brazilians saying what a mess their country was and how it could do nothing right—but at least they could be proud of Ayrton Senna. Brazilians can think of plenty to be proud of today, said Mr Blair—and when speaking in Africa he sometimes tells his hosts about the Ayrton Senna documentary, concluding that if Brazil can come so far in such a short time, so can they. "The story of Brazil over the last 20 years is inspiring," he said. "If I had to bet on the fortunes of the big emerging markets," said Mr Clinton, "I would bet on Brazil first."
Photo credit: SM2 Fotografia

Ciencia: Curiosidad, mirada crítica y escepticismo



Curiosidad, mirada crítica y escepticismo
La investigadora del CONICET y conductora televisiva Melina Furman, especialista en educación de la ciencia, sostiene que cultivar la curiosidad, la mirada crítica y el escepticismo es esencial para pensar lo que nos rodea, intentar comprenderlo y tomar decisiones fundamentadas.
Agencia CyTA Instituto Leloir/El Arca
Curiosidad, mirada crítica y escepticismo
Melina Furman escribe y conduce el
programa de ciencia para chicos “La
Casa de la Ciencia”, que se emite
por el canal de TV Paka Paka.
Doctora en Educación de la Ciencia de la Universidad de Columbia, licenciada en Ciencias Biológicas de la UBA, profesora de la Universidad de San Andrés, investigadora del Conicet, cofundadora de Expedición Ciencia y conductora del programa “La casa de la ciencia”, que se emite por la señal Paka Paka, Melina Furman está convencida de que los “hábitos de la mente” que hacen al pensamiento científico no son innatos sino que se aprenden. En una entrevista con la Agencia CyTA, Furman habló acerca de diversas estrategias para promover el pensamiento científico en las escuelas.

-¿Por qué es tan importante la enseñanza de las ciencias?


-El pensamiento científico, central a la idea de ciencia como proceso, es una herramienta básica para pensar lo que nos rodea, intentar comprenderlo y  tomar decisiones fundamentadas. Y para que eso suceda los docentes tenemos que generar situaciones que les ofrezcan a los alumnos la oportunidad de “hacer ciencia” en el aula: por ejemplo, investigando fenómenos, pensando maneras válidas de responder preguntas, proponiendo explicaciones alternativas ante los resultados o debatiendo entre pares. Es una aventura desafiante pero también muy posible.

-Precisamente, en 2009 usted fue coautora del libro “La aventura de enseñar Ciencias Naturales” (Aique, 2009). ¿La obra refleja su postura acerca de cómo enseñar ciencia en las escuelas?

-El libro busca tender puentes entre las teorías didácticas y lo que los maestros pueden hacer en el aula para transformar sus clases en espacios de desafío intelectual y entusiasmo por aprender ciencias. El enfoque que sostiene el libro comienza por presentar una analogía de la ciencia que me resulta muy útil para pensar la enseñanza y trabajar con docentes: si nos imaginamos a la ciencia como una moneda de dos caras inseparables, una de ellas es la cara de la ciencia como producto (lo que sabemos, esos hechos e ideas que suelen llenar los pizarrones y los libros de texto), pero la otra, y la habitualmente más ausente en las aulas y más cercana al corazón del espíritu científico, es la de la ciencia como proceso, como una manera muy particular, apasionante y poderosa de acercarse al conocimiento,  ese “cómo sabemos lo que sabemos”. A ese enfoque, que contempla esta mirada dual de la ciencia para pensar su enseñanza, se lo ha llamado “enseñanza por indagación” y viene cobrando mucha fuerza en todo el mundo en las últimas décadas.

-¿Podría dar ejemplos de esa “enseñanza por indagación”?

 -Ejemplos por suerte hay montones. Le cuento un caso: imagínese un grupo de chicos de primaria en un aula, trabajando con su maestra en una unidad sobre las propiedades físicas del sonido. La clase empieza por una pregunta: ¿qué hace falta para que escuchemos un sonido? La docente elige muy bien algunos elementos que los chicos, en grupo, exploran: un parche con granos de arroz encima, por ejemplo, que al hacer sonar el parche se mueven; dos teléfonos caseros, con dos vasitos y un hilo en el medio que “tiembla” cuando uno habla desde uno de los vasos; un diapasón sonando cuya punta se apoya dentro del aula y genera olitas… La docente presenta materiales cuidadosamente elegidos para que los chicos puedan encontrar un elemento en común: para que exista un sonido tiene que haber algo que vibre (el parche, el hilo, la punta del diapasón). Este enfoque genera oportunidades de investigación muy guiadas para que los chicos vayan construyendo ideas claves de la ciencia y, además, aprendiendo habilidades científicas.

-Por ejemplo, la de hacer nuevas preguntas.


Claro. Una siguiente pregunta para retomar la primera conclusión y extenderla más allá podría ser: ¿qué hace que un sonido sea más intenso que otro? ¿O que sea más agudo que otro? ¿Cómo puedo relacionar estas dos propiedades con la vibración de los objetos que generan el sonido? Se trata de trabajar con los chicos a partir de secuencias de investigaciones muy guiadas, complementadas con trabajos de recolección de datos y discusión de resultados.

-¿Es central la capacitación de los docentes?


Sí, es realmente central. No solo aquí en Argentina sino en todo el mundo. La investigación educativa muestra una y otra vez que son los docentes los que hacen la verdadera diferencia en qué y cuánto aprenden los chicos, más que cualquier otro factor. Tener docentes capacitados tanto en los contenidos específicos de la ciencia como en sus modos de generar conocimiento, con la capacidad de elaborar e implementar buenas secuencias de enseñanza y con la mirada puesta en seguir las trayectorias de los chicos es la única garantía de que la enseñanza de las ciencias mejore.

-¿El docente tiene estímulos para formarse en este campo?


 Cuando a los docentes se les ofrecen buenas oportunidades de capacitación, con modelos centrados en los contenidos que hay que enseñar en cada año o grado, y complementadas por un acompañamiento real en la escuela, las cosas empiezan a mejorar muy rápidamente. Y la mejora se ve en varios frentes: tanto en la satisfacción de los docentes con sus prácticas como en la participación y el aprendizaje de los chicos en la clase.

 -¿Cultivar el pensamiento científico sólo beneficia a quienes van a seguir una carrera en ciencias?


Como una apasionada por la educación en ciencias y su poder para generar una ciudadanía hacia una más curiosa y al mismo tiempo más racional sostengo que el pensamiento científico nos ayuda a pensar nuestros propios problemas, a generar innovación y a transformarnos en el país que queremos ser. Por eso es tan importante una buena enseñanza de la ciencia para todos los que no van a ser científicos, para que parte de su modo de ver el mundo incluya la curiosidad, la mirada crítica y el escepticismo, que son valores íntimamente asociados a la ciencia como aventura intelectual.

Sociólogo diz que violência migrou dos grandes centros e destaca impunidade





Railton Teixeira
Alagoas24horas
Sociólogo diz que violência migrou dos grandes centros e destaca impunidade
Sociólogo diz que violência migrou dos grandes centros e destaca impunidade
“As causas da violência em Alagoas também se dão pela ausência do poder do Estado, onde não tem como enfrentar esse modelo internacional de crime”, destacou o organizador do Mapa da Violência na America Latina, Julio Jacobo Waiselfisz, que esteve na manhã desta quarta-feira, 29, na Câmara Municipal de Maceió.
Jacobo foi ouvido pela Comissão Especial de Inquérito que analisa as causas da violência na capital alagoana, que, em sua terceira audiência, trouxe ao parlamento mirim o ex-coordenador da Unesco, área Pernambuco, para apresentar dados que coloca o Estado como mais violento do país e a capital como a terceira mais violenta do mundo.
De acordo com Waiselfisz, um dos maiores motivos para o crescente número da violência da capital se deu pelas greves da polícia, ocorridas nas últimas décadas, onde segundo ele “foi uma festa para a bandidagem”.
Para o sociólogo, a impunidade e a aliança do Estado são os motivadores da violência, onde segundo ele, os índices começaram a crescer “assustadoramente” a partir de 1999, havendo assim uma mudança de padrões e os estados que eram mais violentos tiveram uma redução e os estados, a exemplo de Alagoas, com baixo índice triplicou.
“A violência se espalhou por todo o Estado, houve uma interiorização, principalmente com o crescimento da economia, que aliado a isso aqui não há uma polícia preparada”, destacou, enfatizando ainda que “quem pode se proteger vive e quem não pode fica à mercê da violência”.
Ainda segundo ele, para cada branco assassinado, 20 negros são “exterminados” no Estado. “Os homicídios de brancos diminuíram, agora em relação aos povos negros estes números só cresceram e com relação a 2013 este número só tende a crescer”, enfatizou.
Segundo o sociólogo e pesquisador da ação policial contra a população negra em Alagoas, Carlos Martins, que também foi vítima de uma ação policial equivocada, os crimes contra a população negra são históricos e consequentemente estão relacionados com a formação dos agentes de polícia.
“O que há na verdade é uma marginalização da população negra e principalmente a polícia acha que o negro tem relação com os crimes, já a elite representa segurança, ou seja, a repressão contra o negro é latente”, enfatizou Martins.

Mapa da Violência

Segundo Jacobo, o Mapa da Violência segue a contagem por duas fontes oficiais, os boletins passado pela polícia de cada estado e pelos números fornecidos pelo Ministério da Justiça.
“Contabilizamos todos os tipos de homicídios, não apenas aqueles que são Crimes Violentos Letais e Intencionais, os conhecidos CVLI, mas também todas as formas de crimes relacionados à pessoa humana”, concluiu.

Disponible la conferencia de Manuel Castells Une autre économie est possible


Se encuentra disponible la conferencia (en francés) que Manuel Castells dictara en la Maison de l'Amérique Latine en París el pasado 26 de junio. En esta intervención, titulada Une autre économie est possible e introducida por Alain Touraine, el sociólogo español expone la esencia de las ideas planteadas en dos libros de reciente aparición Aftermath. The cultures of the economic crisis y Networks of Outrage and Hope: Social Movements in the Internet Age, y uno más que será publicado a finales de 2012.
—Vía @FondationMSH

Best Practices for Deploying iPads in Schools



Flickr: Lexie Flickinger
By Matt Levinson
As schools get ready to deploy iPads this year, each one is scrambling to figure out how to develop an efficient and effective system that works. With no standardized system or uniform roadmap to follow, at the moment, it’s up to individual schools to reach out through their networks to find information about best practices and smooth, streamlined service.
Without professional development and a set plan in place, educators in individual classes might be stumped by how to set up iPads for different uses. But once a system is in place, educators will intuitively be able to move on with the business of guiding student learning.
To that end, here are some ideas about how to put a system in place for iPad use in classrooms:
  • Establish clearly written Frequently Asked Questions a sensible Responsible Use Policy and a white paper that explains the rationale behind the decision to move to iPads, but also be flexible and nimble with policy as iPads and the best uses for them continue to evolve.
  • Include the responsible use policy or acceptable use policy as a PDF in the iBooks app on the iPad so students and teachers can readily access.
  • Provide students with photos of proper care and post these photos around key areas of campus as reminders (with a short checklist on essential care).
  • Create short video tutorials on how to use different apps.
  • Develop a few surveys throughout the year to gather feedback to make mid-course corrections.
  • Take photos of classroom set up, with projectors and audio, and post these photos in every classroom, with a short cheat sheet of directions. Create a job in each classroom where students take ownership of the process of ensuring that all systems are working. This will minimize loss of instructional time spent on malfunctioning wiring or connectivity.
  • Share best practices and successes with short videos and student presentations with parents, and enlist students as ambassadors to teach adults how to use iPads. This can happen at a parent education event or another similar event.
  • Track paper and waste reduction. The shift to iPads makes the paperless classroom a possibility. Have each class monitor their use of paper and printing and set targets for each class, grade level and the entire school.
  • Track app usage to find out which apps are most used and most effective.
  • Have teachers share best practices at staff meetings. Those who take the lead can help their colleagues figure out how to use apps effectively to deepen student learning. These trainings can occur at staff meetings or in smaller groups at department meetings and should be a regular part of the learning cycle for teachers, who then teach their students.
Matt Levinson is the Head of the Upper Division at Marin Country Day School in Corte Madera, Calif. and the author of From Fear to Facebook: One School’s Journey.

Are kids really motivated by technology?


Guest Blogger

By Bill Ferriter on August 17th, 2012 | 
)
As a guy who delivers two-day #edtech workshops during my breaks from full-time classroom teaching, I’m often asked the same questions again and again: How can teachers use technology to motivate students? What digital tools do kids like best?
My answer often catches participants by surprise: You can’t motivate students with technology because technology alone isn’t motivating. Worse yet, students are almost alwaysambivalent toward digital tools. While you may be completely jazzed by the interactive whiteboard in your classroom or the wiki that you just whipped up, your kids could probably care less.
Need proof?
Early in my technology integration efforts, I set up a blog for my students, introduced it excitedly to every class, and proceeded to get exactly zero posts in the first two months of its existence despite my near-constant begging and pleading. If technology was inherently motivating, my students would have been completely consumed by our classroom blog, willingly writing and sharing their thoughts at all hours of the day, right?
But they weren’t, and my grand blogging experiment died before it ever really began.
The lesson I learned was a simple one: Technology, as Dina Strasser likes to say, is a motivational red herring. While kids may initially love technology-inspired lessons in schools simply because they are different from the paper-driven work that tends to define traditional classrooms, the novelty of new tools wears off a lot quicker than digital cheerleaders like to admit.
What students are really motivated by are opportunities to be social — to interact around challenging concepts in powerful conversations with their peers. They are motivated by issues connected to fairness and justice. They are motivated by the important people in their lives, by the opportunity to wrestle with the big ideas rolling around in their minds, and by the often-troubling changes they see happening in the world around them.
Technology’s role in today’s classroom, then, isn’t to motivate. It’s to give students opportunities to efficiently and effectively participate in motivating activities built around the individuals and ideas that matter to them.
Popular classroom tools such as VoiceThread don’t excite kids — but the kinds of content-driven, asynchronous conversations between peers that they enable, do. Websites such as Kiva aren’t motivating — but the real-world exposure to the impact of poverty on people in the developing world that they enable, is. Services such as Twitter are simple in-and-of themselves — but the opportunity to quickly sort and search for filtered resources connected to almost any topic matters to today’s learners.
Basically what I’m arguing is that finding ways to motivate students in our classrooms shouldn’t start with conversations about technology. Instead, it should start with conversations about our kids. What are they deeply moved by? What are they most interested in? What would surprise them? Challenge them? Leave them wondering? Once you have the answers to these questions — only after you have the answers to these questions — are you ready to make choices about the kinds of digital tools that are worth embracing.
Like many accomplished educators, Bill Ferriter (@plugusin) wears a ton of professional hats. He’s a Solution Tree author and presenter, an accomplished blogger and a senior fellow in the Teacher Leaders Network. He checks all of those titles at the door each morning, though, when he walks into his classroom.