7 de outubro de 2014

Abuse Cases at 2 Schools, With Technology at the Root



Continue reading the main storyShare This Page
MAPLEWOOD, N.J. — The New York Times
The allegations of teachers’ preying on students have come from two very different area high schools in the last two weeks: one in this well-off suburb, the other at a selective school in the heart of Brooklyn. In one case, a woman is accused of having sex with five boys; in the other, it is a man, accused of crossing the line with seven girls.
Both were teachers who seemed more like friends, known for giving easy A’s. And both cases are defined by technology: Prosecutors say the adults groomed the students using text messages.
They sent sexually provocative pictures on the Snapchat app, believing them to be private. In Maplewood, the teacher apparently allowed sex with one boy to be captured on video, which students then circulated in the hallways.
Schools have struggled with teacher-student relationships probably forever, and most famously since Mary Kay Letourneau was arrested in Washington State in 1997 for having sex with a 12-year-old student.


But only recently have schools had to deal with relationships enabled by new technology. In the past five years, many schools have responded with social media policies. Last year, a West Virginia district banned any personal texting between teachers and students; three years ago, Missouri passed a law barring teachers from using any “non-work-related Internet site which allows access” to past or current students.

Photo

Sean M. Shaynak, a teacher at Brooklyn Technical High School, is charged with having sex with female students. CreditByron Smith

Parents and school administrators alike fear it has become harder to maintain boundaries when teachers routinely give out their cellphone numbers to talk about homework. And a new generation of teachers has grown up communicating primarily through the Internet or texting, where divisions between work and private life easily blur.
“This is an American problem more than a Maplewood problem,” said Kate McCaffrey, the mother of a Columbia High School student here who alerted school officials last spring when she heard that the teacher arrested in September, Nicole Dufault, had sent naked pictures of herself to a student on Snapchat.
“The teachers say to the students, ‘Any problem, feel free to call me.’ ”
“The children are living in this social media world that the adults don’t get,” Ms. McCaffrey added.
Texting and social media have made it easier for teachers to get directly to students, but they can also make sexual misconduct easier to prosecute. In Maplewood and in Brooklyn, parents have used the cases to argue how hard it is to get rid of bad teachers. But tenured teachers can be fired for immoral conduct, and texts and videos can make that plain.
“The Internet allows things that were previously hidden and hard to see to come to light,” said David Finkelhor, the director of the Crimes Against Children Research Center at the University of New Hampshire.

Photo

Nicole Dufault is charged with having sex with three male high school students in Maplewood, N.J., while she was a teacher at Columbia High School.CreditEssex County, N.J., Prosecutor's Office

“In the old days, if the inappropriate activities started with the gym teacher putting his hands on the student’s breasts, if she was uncomfortable and went to tell somebody about it, it might not go anywhere, or he would say, ‘No, she was mistaken.’ If he sends a picture of himself in his underwear or says something sexually provocative in a text exchange, that’s easier to prosecute and easier for the young people or their parents to bring to official attention.”
New York City schools adopted a social media policy two years ago after several teachers were arrested on accusations of inappropriate sexual contact with students. It barred teachers from contacting students on websites like Twitter and Facebook, but did not address contact by text message or cellphone. And complaints of sexual misconduct have risen each year since, according to city records.
It is harder to quantify the problem nationally. Surveys that rely on self-reporting suggest that cases of sexual abuse have declined since use of the Internet became pervasive, Mr. Finkelhor said. The surveys do not break out cases of sexual abuse in schools. And no national database does so.
In Maplewood, parents had long complained about Ms. Dufault, 35, who taught mostly lower-level English courses. Last year, several parents said, they told administrators that she made inappropriate comments in class — about a miscarriage, about her sex life, about her divorce. Administrators spoke to her about it, parents said, but she went back to the classroom and complained that someone had told on her.
In June, Ms. McCaffrey’s daughter told her there was a video of a boy opening a Snapchat picture from a teacher, in which she appeared to be masturbating.
Her daughter clammed up when asked who the teacher or the student was. But a friend of Ms. McCaffrey’s asked her son, who asked friends. “They all knew, ‘Oh, yeah, that’s Ms. Dufault,’ ” Ms. McCaffrey said. Several had seen the video. “This was just another day at school.”

Photo

Brooklyn Technical High School.CreditChang W. Lee/The New York Times

Ms. McCaffrey told school administrators, who apparently called students in to ask about the video. It was unclear what they learned. (School officials have declined to comment since the arrest.) The police asked Ms. McCaffrey whether her daughter would give a sworn statement. “I said, ‘No, then I’ll never hear anything from her again.’ ”
Other parents said the police went to the boy, who denied having the video.
Ms. Dufault taught in the school’s summer program for at-risk students in July. By then, court papers say, she had already had sex with four of the five boys — four are 15, one is 17 — in her car and on high school property. Those assaults, as they are considered under New Jersey law, continued as she taught summer school, court papers say.
This fall, parents said, students began sending around a video showing Ms. Dufault performing oral sex on one of the boys.
On Sept. 18, students learned in an announcement from the principal that a teacher had been arrested. Ms. Dufault’s classroom was roped off with a sign calling it “unusable.” The principal asked students and teachers not to speak to the news media.
Ms. Dufault’s lawyer, Timothy Smith, said she had a shunt put in her brain during surgery to correct a problem that surfaced during pregnancy. That, he said, may have made her vulnerable to being a “victim.”

Photo

Nicole Dufault taught at Columbia High School, above, in Maplewood, N.J., and Sean M. Shaynak at Brooklyn Technical High School. They are accused of sexually abusing students. CreditBryan Thomas for The New York Times

Parents have wondered why it took so long to recognize the problem, when there had been complaints about Ms. Dufault.
In an interview, one parent recalled a French teacher who talked to students about his sex life. The school let him go after his first year of teaching there. But only one student complained; other students were reluctant to come forward.
“The mentality of the kids is bizarre,” said the parent, who did not want to be identified because of the sensitivity of the situation. “They didn’t want to get this guy in trouble.”
Students and parents said the same was true of Ms. Dufault and Sean M. Shaynak, the 44-year-old Brooklyn Technical High School teacher accused of pursuing seven girls, giving some of them alcohol and cigarettes, taking one to a nude beach and another to a sex club, sending them suggestive text messages and photos and having sex with two of them after they reached the legal age of consent. Both teachers were liked by students because their classes were easy and they acted more like friends than teachers.
Social media has blurred that boundary, particularly for younger teachers and high school students.
“They grew up with cellphones attached to their hands or the Internet that was less a tool and more a place where they lived and worked and conversed,” said Sonja H. Trainor, senior staff attorney for the National School Boards Association. “They didn’t really have the same understanding of divisions between private and work life.”
Schools have sought policies to make those boundaries clearer, she said, but not always successfully. A judge ruled the Missouri statute too broad, because it would have blocked teachers from sites like Facebook, Twitter and even Gmail. The state then repealed it. Last year, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that a statute banning sexually explicit online communication between adults and minors violated the First Amendment.
The school boards group is pushing the Supreme Court to take an online-speech case, Ms. Trainor said. Until then, she said, “we’re still figuring out the appropriate lines.”

Nenhum comentário:

Postar um comentário